Black and White

October 30, 2016

Released August 2012

Following the sensational ‘Protect and Survive,’ ‘Black and White’ continues this latest Seventh Doctor trilogy with a tale that finally offers answers to questions that have been building since Hex’s first appearance. Fitting in Doctor Who’s take on the Beowulf legend as well as the monstrous Garundel ravishes the kingdom of Hrothgar, ‘Black and White’ comes precariously close on multiple instances of collapsing under its own weight and ambition but ultimately tells a very intriguing story that sets up the final story of this trilogy incredibly well.

The answers are revealed at a fairly consistent pace, and the first episode is largely a standalone one that focuses on Sophie Aldred’s Ace, Philip Olivier’s Hex, Maggie O’Neill’s Lyssandra from ‘Project: Destiny,’ and Amy Pemberton’s Sally from ‘House of Blue Fire’ slowly figuring out what is going on around them. As it turns out, the TARDIS’s white façade over the past several stories is not just a meaningless colour change, and the Doctor has also been using a corresponding black TARDIS to help with recruitment of soldiers in his eternal battle against the Elder Gods. Hex and Sally create a very natural pairing, though their quick comfort with each other in these circumstances may foreshadow an unfortunate ending for one or both. More importantly, though, is Ace once again having her faith in the Doctor challenged as his duplicity reveals itself, hearkening back to her encounter with Fenric in the television classic ‘The Curse of Fenric.’

As the companions follow in the Doctor’s wake, trying to prepare for the oncoming battle in the process, the flashback sequences that show the Doctor secretly raising the black TARDIS from a childhood-like state in order to run side missions without Ace and Hex knowing are brilliantly realized. The Seventh Doctor is no stranger to darker inclinations, but these actions while knowingly bringing the black TARDIS closer to its demise in the final battle are unquestionably some of the darkest actions he’s ever undertaken and significantly heighten the overall severity and menace of the threat at hand.

Even as allusions to Fenric continue to mount, the threat manifesting through Nordic bloodlines a rather pointed comparison, ‘Black and White’ still spends ample time with its Beowulf component as well. With Hex and Sally encountering the legendary king near the end of his life and Ace and Lyssandra encountering a much more youthful version, even this component takes effectively unpredictable turns, and the close interconnectedness of truth and fiction is explored to great effect within the confines of the king’s life. Though Michael Rouse may go just a little too over the top as the young king, Richard Bremmer touchingly exudes the temper of age as required, and Stuart Milligan’s alien Garundel is just nuanced enough to fit in tonally with these harrowing events.

As Sylvester McCoy is once more largely absent from this story due to his filming obligations for The Hobbit, Aldred and Olivier masterfully carry their second story in a row. At the same time, O’Neill and Pemberton each give suitably strong performances that exemplify why the Doctor chose those two to join his crusade. And although there is definitely too much going on for every aspect to be explored sufficiently, McCoy’s flashback scenes are unquestionably some of the highlights of this release, proving once more that Big Finish and its authors are perfectly able to successfully work around unexpected hurdles. It would have been nice to see the discussion of reality and fiction tied into the storyline of the companions and Doctor as well, but the end result is still a very strong effort that rewards long-time Big Finish listeners and sets up the highly-anticipated conclusion very effectively.

Wrap Up

Black and White

Pros

  • + Great flashback sequences with McCoy and the black TARDIS
  • + Four companions carry the story admirably as they slowly uncover the truth
  • + Sets up the conclusion wonderfully

Cons

  • - Too many plot points to adequately explore each
  • - Occasional campy and over the top performance

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *